Greetings, my lovelies!
By now you may have heard the, um, "controversy" (my God, is that word overused) surrounding the new Amy Sherman-Palladino show,
Bunheads. Shonda Rhimes, of
Grey's Anatomy/Private Practice/Scandal fame, tweeted the following after the pilot of
Bunheads:
“Hey @abcfbunheads: really? You couldn’t cast even ONE young dancer of color so I could feel good about my kid watching this show? NOT ONE?”
She quickly added that while she was a major
Gilmore Girls fan (Amy S-P's most famous show to date) and that she liked that girls of all sizes were aspiring ballerinas, she was just pointing out a few issues.
Amy S-P has since responded, essentially saying that Shonda shouldn't have attacked her like that, that women shouldn't go after each other like that, etc. etc. Which, yes. I agree, but um...that's not what Shonda was getting at. Too bad Amy didn't have anything to say regarding Shonda's point re: the all-white cast. The only thing she really said about it was that she'd had "no time" to look for a diverse cast.
Whatever that means.
Non-answers aside, who's right in this situation? Can you even argue that one of them is right and one of them isn't? Let's take a look.
On the one hand, we can make a case for diversity. There should be more races represented on television and movies, period. There
are small towns with mostly white folk in America (where
Bunheads takes place), but those are getting harder to find. There are so many talented people of colour who deserve the chance to play roles other than ones that are written specifically for them.
A good example of this is, not surprisingly,
Grey's Anatomy, which if you believe Shonda Rhimes, had colourblind casting. Some people poohpooh this idea, pointing out that the male and female leads are white. This is true. And of the five original interns, only one is not white. BUT. If you think you can call that cast anything but diverse, you need to watch again. Not only are there many non-white characters, there are characters of all different races and ethnic backgrounds - black, Asian, Hispanic. There's even a racially mixed character, if I'm not mistaken (helllloooo, Avery!). Even better, though, is that these characters are all strong, intelligent and often fearless characters, with nary a racial stereotype in sight. Even 50% or more of the guest actors (usually the patients) are coloured. This is an example of diversity at its finest, and I honestly believe that Shonda doesn't get enough credit for having such a racially diverse cast and not ever really touching on it - the characters' race is a part of who they are, but they don't exist for the sake of having diveristy-charged storylines. An honest congrats to you, Ms. Rhimes.
But on the other hand...
If I'm being honest, "tokenism" really bothers me. Shoehorning a character of colour
just for the sake of having a character of colour is obnoxious and kind of insulting. It just screams "Hey everybody, look! We have a/an [race/ethnicity that isn't white] person on our show! Look at how
diverse we are!". Even worse is when that character's racial/ethnicity is stereotyped to be funny. Ugh.
Shonda's comment about not feeling good about her kid watching the show because of the all-white cast rubs me the wrong way. You can still like and relate to a character and what they're going through even if you don't look like them. And if the only way you can relate to a character is by the colour of their skin, well...maybe you need take a look inside and ask yourself why that is.
And I gotta ask - would this have been a problem with Shonda if the cast had been all black?
One final point on the "boourns to tokenism" side - in all fairness, this
is just the pilot. There are many more characters to be introduced, I'm sure, and who's to say they're going to be all white, too?
I think that if possible, producers/directors/what-have-yous should pull a Shonda and do colourblind casting. Pick the actor or actress that's best for the part and disregard the colour of their skin. That said, it's important to keep in mind that sometimes, it's going to be a white person, and that acting is still, at this point, a mainly white-dominated profession. Is it because more white people get cast, or because more white people persue the profession? Chicken or the egg? Who knows?
Colourblind casting for all!